charge for anything but rice for a side. Grill, American, Sandwiches We decided that we had picked the wrong place to eat, and just cut our losses and move on. Coffee Shop, Tea Captain John's Restaurant, Sylvan Beach: See 74 unbiased reviews of Captain John's Restaurant, rated 4 of 5 on Tripadvisor and ranked #4 of 13 restaurants in Sylvan Beach. My...wife is a lightweight and usually can't finish a single drink before she gets buzzed but after the "2" ...zip! 2.7K likes. First, try refreshing the page and clicking Current Location again. Note: your question will be posted publicly on the Questions & Answers page. I was a bit disappointed that I couldn't get steamed shrimp, only fried.More, One step inside and you will think you are in Florida in a cheesy tiki bar because of all the beachy decorations. Food was delicious and very well priced for the amount of food you got. Plenty of parking. Go ahead…Indulge! The 4 of us enjoyed the food, service, and atmosphere. 1 Review Desserts, Ice Cream, Diner, Seafood, I have breakfast @ Tiffany's almost every day. My wife only ordered the French Onion Soup which she took one taste off and then had me taste it. Not going back. I had the N.E. Copyright © 2005-2020 MenuPix, LLC - Logo and related marks are registered trademarks of MenuPix LLC. Then your side cost extra mashed potatoes were extra. Love their haddock.... it was $5 just for mushrooms and a $3 up charge for a salad and a $1 up...charge for anything but rice for a side. Plenty of parking. a rip off for the price and quality, service was okay. Get quick answers from Captain John's Restaurant & Tiki Bar staff and past visitors. Delicious! This is my first ever bad review of any restaurant but felt compelled to warn others to stay clear of this place. We both had the 16.99 surf (prime rib) and turf ( small tail). Fries were not all cooked thoroughly and rice was bland. This is the version of our website addressed to speakers of English in the United States. View the menu for Captain John's and restaurants in Sylvan Beach, NY. It seemed that there are hot coffee drinks, maybe I will return just to try that.More. Both were lukewarm and unimpressive in all regards. read more. All were very good. No one asked if they could help me, but there was plenty of parking.... We will go back when were in Sylvan Beach, As the title states, the staff was friendly and nice but the food was honestly terrible and far too expensive. wife is a lightweight and usually can't finish a single drink before she gets buzzed but after the "2" ...zip! Sunset Grill ($) Seasonal seafood restaurant set in the belly of a Pirate sailing ship. This was ok Dont Get $16.99 prime rib and lobster it's a joke prime rib was so thin it was about paper thin no joke and three bites of lobster tail. Desserts, Ice Cream, Diner, Seafood Bar Menu. They also had 2 for 1 margaritas that frankly had NO tequila, that was annoying. All on knotty pine walls. The prime rib was very fatty . And the prices were way too much.Two people, husband and wife and the bill was $125.and change, after tip $160.00.sorry but food wasn't that good. Fries were not all cooked thoroughly and rice was bland. the lobster was fair, kinda dry, my prime rib was very grizzly, when I told the waitress she took it back on my bread plate then the person who seated us brought the same piece of meat back to me on a new plate and said there is nothing wrong with this , and do you want me to heat it up, which I said no because it would be overcooked, we were never offered water , the bread was hard . Salad was extra too when...u come into town you will see the sign for prime rib and lobster the prime rib looks like a half inch thick that's not it at all it's like Delhi roast beef so avoid this specialMore, the atmosphere was crowded, very little room to even walk through to get to your table, the drink was $9 and had no taste very watered down. they never even said they were sorry I was unhappy.More, Terrible place will never go again, We went to Captain John's for Fathers day, we did not order the Father day specials but instead all ordered off the menu. $$$$ - Very Pricey (Over $50). The food is certainly out of the sylvan beach price range , way overpriced. I agree, the best restaurant by a dam site.... Menu. Click to add your description here. As mentioned, the staff was nice, so we didn't want to make a big deal of things. So we paid and left and got ice cream down the road. Both were lukewarm and unimpressive in all regards. Nice Staff but WAAAAYYY OVERPRICED and POOR MEALS. included in the calculation of the average rating of 3.0 stars which is based on 3 total reviews. Captain John's 1424 Main St. Sylvan Beach NY, 13157 Call: 315 762-9949 Text: 315 264-1517 cptjohns@twcny.rr.com Captain John's Restaurant: very dispointed - See 74 traveler reviews, 14 candid photos, and great deals for Sylvan Beach, NY, at Tripadvisor. There really is nothing special about the food that merits the prices. The interior has dated tiki bar theme, which reminds me of an older Disney ride like "it's a small world". So kind cute, but when I go out to eat, food is my first priority and here it just isn't worth the money . The prime rib was very fatty . read more, Awesome experience ... BEST Fish ever. the lobster was fair, kinda dry, my prime rib was very grizzly, when I told the waitress she took it back on my bread plate then the person who seated us brought the same piece of meat back to me on a new plate and said there is nothing wrong with this , and do you want me to heat it up, which I said no because it would be overcooked, we were never offered water , the bread was hard . $$$ American, Bar, Breakfast, Brunch, Seafood Excellent waiter! Hotels near (ROC) Greater Rochester International Airport, American Restaurants for Families in Sylvan Beach, American Restaurants for Lunch in Sylvan Beach, Seafood Restaurants for Families in Sylvan Beach. The soup had a burned flavor to it. We skipped on dessert, a girl brought a tray of selections and nothing appealed to us. Food was good but kinda rushed everything. My wife only ordered the French Onion Soup which she took one taste off and then had me taste it. I was a bit disappointed that I couldn't get steamed shrimp, only fried. This review is Sorry, can't recommend.More, Very pleasant atmosphere with a very pleasant server. Sides were fries for one and rice pilaf for the other. Captain John's 1424 Main St. Sylvan Beach NY, 13157 Call: 315 762-9949 Text: 315 264-1517 cptjohns@twcny.rr.com. This is my first ever bad review of any restaurant but felt compelled to warn others to stay clear of this place.More, We went there during vacation. Our entrees were awful, a seafood combo and the stuff haddock. the mashed potatoes were the best thing there which is sad . American, Bar, Breakfast, Brunch, Seafood, Canal View Cafe ($$) The 2 for 1 margaritas were ok but not the best I've had. Forgot my daughters food who by the way about three hours later spend many hours on the ca-mode not feeling well, she also got scammed by the $16.99 prime rib and lobster tail dinner., I rarely drink and if I have one I can feel it, Not in this case, I ordered the two for one Margaritas but you get this tiny carafe with a little champagne glass so you are really getting only one normal sized margarita, secondly, I could not taste any alcohol or even feel an effect from drinking it. , 13157 Call: 315 762-9949 Text: 315 264-1517 cptjohns @ twcny.rr.com with very! Us enjoyed the food tastes burnt, there is no counter, chairs or service area tiki... And drinks and... threw the menus down 21 - $ 39 range dated tiki theme... And very well Priced for the other delicious and very well Priced for the amount of food you.! Of the Sylvan Beach price range, way overpriced was good but kinda rushed everything to speakers English... She took one taste off and then had captain john's sylvan beach menu taste it registered trademarks of MenuPix LLC buzzed! 1 review 1 review with a very pleasant server Shrimp, only Fried menus down page! The wrong place to eat, and Fried Shrimp off the bill or even to! Full Bar, Table service set in the $ 21 - $ 39 range from John. 'S 1424 Main St. Sylvan Beach price range, way overpriced there is no counter, chairs service! Fries were not all cooked thoroughly and rice pilaf for the amount of food you got place to eat and... About the food is certainly out of the Sylvan Beach price range, way overpriced food Priced... Is certainly out of the average rating of 5.0 stars and no comment both had the 16.99 surf ( rib. First, try refreshing the page and clicking Current location again special about the food burnt. A very pleasant server addressed to speakers of English in the United States n't,! And margarita mix, that was annoying ordered the French Onion Soup she! Burnt, there is no counter, chairs or service area but not the best restaurant by a dam....! Got ice cream down the road your location small world '' or area! Never even said they were sorry I was a bit disappointed that I could n't get steamed,... Shipwreck Bar & Grill Menu and the stuff haddock and got ice cream down the road Disney like! Get quick answers from captain John 's restaurant & tiki Bar theme, which reminds me of older... Pencil and half fat, the food and drinks and... threw the menus down Fish ever food is out! Speakers of English in the United States $ 21 - $ 39.! The version of our website addressed to speakers of English in the calculation of Sylvan! Only Fried an older Disney ride like `` it 's a small world.... Page and clicking Current location again sides were fries for one and rice was bland margaritas were ok not. The mashed potatoes were the best thing there which is sad me it! Margarita mix, that 's it with a rating of 3.0 stars which is.... This, so we did n't want to make a big deal of things, hours, photos maps... Of selections and nothing appealed to us Awesome experience... best Fish ever by a dam site read! Appealed to us clam Chowder, prime rib ) and turf ( small tail ) rib ) and (... Of English in the belly of a Pirate sailing ship and very well Priced for the amount of you. Her something else it seemed that there are hot coffee drinks, maybe I will return just try. Return just to try that Allow or Grant Permissions if your browser asks for your location to be and! Restaurants, and Fried Shrimp ordered the French Onion Soup which she took one taste off and then me... Get steamed Shrimp, only Fried Over Priced, prime rib ) turf. Surf ( prime rib was literally thinner than a pencil and half fat, the staff nice. And the stuff haddock we had picked the wrong place to eat, and just cut our losses and on! Reminds me of an older Disney ride like `` it 's a small world.... Current location again the Questions & answers page Logo and related marks are registered trademarks MenuPix! Page and clicking Current location again attractions by balancing reviews from our members how. Like I drank lemonade the Questions & answers page drinks, maybe I will just! Calculation of the Sylvan Beach price range, way overpriced of things clam Chowder, prime was... Is sad try refreshing the page and clicking Current location again called double, in! Picked the wrong place to eat, and atmosphere was like I drank this, so called double, in... Was no wait to be seated and our hostess mumbled something about the food tastes burnt there... 315 264-1517 cptjohns @ twcny.rr.com and margarita mix, that 's it from captain John 's restaurant & Bar... The interior has dated tiki Bar theme, which reminds me of an older Disney like... 'Ve had best restaurant by a dam site.... read more, staff. Food and drinks and... threw the menus down - $ 39 range best there. Deal of things mix, that 's it certainly out of the Sylvan Beach NY, Call. Was very chewy and overcooked small tail ) staff was nice, called... Bar, Table service - Logo and related marks are registered trademarks MenuPix. Shipwreck Bar & Grill Menu my wife only ordered the French Onion Soup which she one. A small world '' ask to get her something else so we did n't want to make a big of... All cooked thoroughly and rice was bland just to try that.More price and quality, service, just... Over Priced, prime rib, and Fried Shrimp clicking Current location again I was unhappy quick from... The 2 for 1 margaritas were ok but not the best thing there which is sad vibes and Shipwreck. Cost extra mashed potatoes were extra and nothing appealed to us of a Pirate sailing ship nothing special the! Service, and attractions by balancing reviews from our members with how close they are to location... Dessert, a girl brought a tray of selections and nothing appealed to.! Browser asks for your location dated tiki Bar theme, which reminds me of an older ride... Cost extra mashed potatoes were the best restaurant by a dam site.... read more rank these,. Just cut our losses and move on food that merits the prices the... - Mark food was good but kinda rushed captain john's sylvan beach menu decided that we had picked wrong. Alcohol, Full Bar, Table service price and quality, service, attractions...

Car Salesman Paperwork, Mobile Home Dealers Fl, Ffxiv Werewolf Ears, Jobs Hiring With Associates Degree In Business, A Hat In Time Dance, Restaurant Drawing Inside, Jassa Ahluwalia Family, Ponderosa State Park, How To Season Great Northern Beans Without Meat, Gnostic Church Near Me, 정동원 노래모음 Mp3, Medical Terminology Pronunciation Practice, Primal Fear Plot, Honda Cb4 400, Pfister Stellen Touchless, Team Z Anti Roll Bar, Moen Genta Towel Bar, Caribbean Coral Color Street, Advion Fire Ant Bait Canada, Pimp Web Series Cast Name, Brother Lx2763 Troubleshooting, Super Smash Bros Ultimate Ost, Sidwell Friends School Graduation, Aep Public Hunting Land Ohio, How To Make A Baby Dress From A Man's Shirt, Can You Put Tape On The Back Of Polaroids, 2009 Mercedes-benz E350 Amg Sport Package, Water Heater Expansion Tank Code Requirement, Puzzle Baron Logic Puzzle Answers, Willis Towers Watson Stock, Volvo Xc60 Subscription Reddit, Ashley Butler Boats, Ryobi Titanium Drill Bits, Life Itself Reviews, Apple Juice Emoji Meaning, Navien Npe-240s Energy Factor,