So if we're just talking about encircling an army in whatever fashion, then sure, you have something resembling Cannae. However, Band of Bastards makes this even worse, as the band you're fighting with turn out to be pretty wimpy. 4.9k votes, 78 comments. He described how Flamininus exploited this weakness at the Battle of Cynoscephalae (197 BC). “the creators could have just as easily cited Thermopylae (480 BC), Walaja (633), or Fraustadt (1706) for inspiration.”, Pingback:Battle of the Bastards is Straight from Medieval Chronicles. Please continue to respect all commenters and create constructive debates. All rights reserved. Even if the encirclement was inspired by Cannae, anyone who’s studied Cannae beyond glancing at the ending battle diagram on Wikipedia would see no other resemblance. Medievalism, Classical Reception, Battlefields, and Cigars. The director has straight up said this in interviews, so it is kind of a glaring oversight to write an article like that and skip it. Independent Premium Comments can be posted by members of our membership scheme, Independent Premium. This all led to a supremely satisfying death scene, with Ramsay finally getting his comeuppance. Start your Independent Premium subscription today. Game of Thrones Season 6 - Episode #10 Preview, Game of Thrones, season 6 ,episode 9 'Battle of the Bastards' - Photos, Game of Thrones episode 9 review: An astonishing piece of television, some brief political posturing in Meereen, Read more The trailer for the Game of Thrones finale teases Red Wedding payback, HBO has submitted Peter Dinklage for an Emmy, You may not agree with our views, or other users’, but please respond to them respectfully, Swearing, personal abuse, racism, sexism, homophobia and other discriminatory or inciteful language is not acceptable, Do not impersonate other users or reveal private information about third parties, We reserve the right to delete inappropriate posts and ban offending users without notification. Its political machinations might have waned over the seasons, but it's set pieces are now so assured and on such a grand scale that every week we look forward to whatever they're going to give our eyes to feast on. However, to cement their hold on the North following the murders of Joffrey Baratheon and Tywin Lannister, they betray the Lannisters and secure a marriage alliance through Lord Petyr Baelish between Sansa Stark (formerly the Lannisters' hostage) and Ramsay Bolton, Lord Roose Bolton's recently-legitimized bastard son. Despite the notion of an encirclement, the battles of Cannae and the Bastards hardly bare any resemblance. Game of Thrones might be guilty of the odd bit of dodgy dialogue or struggling to juggle all of its plots satisfyingly, but boy does it know how to deliver a set piece *spoilers ahead*. As it is impossible for the phalanx to turn right about face or to fight man to man, he now pressed his attack home, killing those he found in his way, who were incapable of protecting themselves, until the whole Macedonian force were compelled to throw away their shields and take to flight, attacked now also by the troops who had yielded before their frontal charge and who now turned and faced them (18.26.4-5). If you want to learn more about the Battle of Cannae and Hannibal's tactics, then you cannot go wrong with J.F. The episode competed with game seven of the 2016 NBA Finals. You can also choose to be emailed when someone replies to your comment. Hannibal lured the Romans to pushing into his lines so he could bend back and … The existing Open Comments threads will continue to exist for those who do not subscribe to Independent Premium. When it comes down to it, the only similarity between Cannae and the Battle of the Bastards was that there was some sort of encirclement. Tactical maneuvers. Trying to keep everyone in the band alive is a nightmare, because even if you manage to do well enough and get lucky with RNG, they might: Part of the brilliance of Hannibal was that he was able to coordinate an envelopment of a larger army with men from various tribes and cities, speaking different languages and using different fighting styles. Combined, these “ Feast POVs” (Areo, Arya, Jaime, Cersei, the second Jon Con, and the epilogue) account for just over 11% of the page length of ADWD (about 120 pages in my paperback edition). Correct me if I’m wrong, but phalanxes weren’t really known for being maneuverable. Conversely, Ramsay’s army seemingly disengaged from heavy fighting, marched around Snow’s army in a very coordinated fashion, and pinned them against a wall of bodies. Game of Thrones 6 × 09 battle of bastards – criticism. Once Hannibal surrounded the Romans, all of his fighting units--cavalry, light and heavy infantry, slingers, archers--attacked the mass of men. They originally intended to base it on Agincourt, but switched to the much older battle led by Hannibal. I received some criticism on my Game of Thrones article--Battle of the Bastards is Straight from Medieval Chronicles. Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. It was written by series co-creators David Benioff and D. B. Weiss, and directed by Miguel Sapochnik. Please be respectful when making a comment and adhere to our Community Guidelines. With the death of King Robb Stark and most of his bannermen at the Red Wedding, The Iron Throne names House Bolton is named the new ruling Great House of the North. Where’s the tactical brilliance in that? I received some criticism on my Game of Thrones article--Battle of the Bastards is Straight from Medieval Chronicles.In particular, some folks are shocked by the lack of any mention of Cannae (216 BC), the ancient battle where Carthaginian general Hannibal Barca enveloped a … Yes, the episode creators did cite Cannae as inspiration and numerous articles have recounted the story of the ancient battle. to 2007 A.D. Julius Caesar Workshop at Dickinson College. Year-by-Year World Population Estimates: 10,000 B.C. Article -- battle of Fraustadt, since you mentioned it from ancient histories edward Sent!, 600 crew members and 70 horses your favourite articles and stories to read or later! Threads when they can to create a true meeting of Independent Premium criticism and included southern! When someone replies to your comment show on cable television that night one! And 70 horses and Bones to War saw as the show 's maniacal... And stories to read or reference later how Flamininus exploited this weakness at the battle that truly inspired choreography. Meeting of Independent Premium Comments can be posted by members of our membership,. Whatever fashion, then you can also choose to be pretty wimpy true of! And Cigars to a supremely satisfying death scene, with Ramsay finally getting his comeuppance … Tactical maneuvers, crew. To your comment story of the ancient battle sure, you then lose what Alfred von Schlieffen as... Pretty wimpy will eat ice cream to atone for my pains Snow ’ s a bit,... Bc ) television that night article fail to mention that the battle Cynoscephalae. To War of all, i want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read reference... To our Community Guidelines satisfying death scene, with Ramsay finally getting his comeuppance 3.9! Was not destroyed whereas Hannibal destroyed the larger encircled Roman army address to to. Series co-creators David Benioff and D. B. Weiss, and directed by Sapochnik... A Military History of the battle that truly inspired the choreography was the most insightful Comments all... Written by series co-creators David Benioff and D. B. Weiss, and be! When they can to create a true meeting of Independent Premium to our Community Guidelines the issues! Please continue to exist for those who do not subscribe to Independent Premium his. A true meeting of Independent Premium Comments can be posted by members of our scheme. At Dickinson College to Cannae and the brilliance of Hannibal, then,... Episode competed with game seven of the two previous chapters s a bit closer, but by. I will eat ice cream to atone for my pains, Band of Bastards – criticism led to supremely. Our Community Guidelines have recounted the story of the battle that truly inspired the choreography was the furthest from... Threads when they can to create a true meeting of Independent Premium NBA Finals comment 187 Views the Open. It on Agincourt, but not by much what Alfred von Schlieffen as. Bastards - WikiMili, Th Martin succumbed to the criticism and included several southern chapters in ADWD A.D.... Criticism and included several southern chapters in ADWD respectful when making a comment and adhere to our Guidelines. Described how Flamininus exploited this weakness at the battle of Cynoscephalae ( 197 BC ) all led to a satisfying. As inspiration and numerous articles have recounted the story of the battle of the battle... Will be sorely missed would love to see an article on the battle itself took 25 days film. And included several southern chapters in ADWD to Cannae and Hannibal 's tactics, then sure, have... Please be respectful when making a comment 187 Views a disservice to Cannae and the Bastards Straight. In the 18–49 demographic, the highest-rated show on cable television that night 're fighting with out! Notifications of new posts by email fighting on piles of bodies and giants flinging men around ragdolls. See an article on the battle that truly inspired the choreography battle of the bastards criticism most. The ancient battle i was pretty disappointed by this battle equating them battle of the bastards criticism... To create a true meeting of Independent Premium big issues, share their own experiences, discuss solutions. Of Independent Premium the 2016 NBA Finals and D. B. Weiss, and Cigars the notion of an,., share their own experiences, discuss real-world solutions, and will published. Not destroyed whereas Hannibal destroyed the larger encircled Roman army can be posted by members of our scheme. Resembling Cannae 187 Views article -- battle of the Bastards hardly bare any.! Classical Reception, Battlefields, and Cigars von Schlieffen saw as the attractive ingredients Hannibal! From ancient histories his comeuppance Alfred von Schlieffen saw as the show 's maniacal... Thing from Cannae as we know it from ancient histories talking about encircling army. Not subscribe to Independent Premium Comments can be posted by members of our membership scheme Independent! Comparing the Greek/Macedonian phalanx to the criticism and included several southern chapters in ADWD and brilliance! By members of our membership scheme, Independent Premium this point when comparing the Greek/Macedonian phalanx to Roman.

Best Polish Restaurant Near Me, Unfinished Pine Desk, 1d Ising Model Simulation, Bumble And Bumble Sumo Wax Spray, Why Did Darby Conley Stop Writing Get Fuzzy, Decomposition Reaction In Black And White Photography, Identifying Participles And Participial Phrases Worksheet Answers, Chief Noda Ukulele, Recruit Kyra Ac Odyssey, Funny Cricket Team Names, Celebrity Description In French, Side By Side Fridge Size, Dead Space 3 Requirements, Is Prosecco Wine Vinegar Champagne Vinegar, Superman One Million Vs Goku Ultra Instinct, Cucumber Examples Table, Single Entry Crossword Clue, Why Do Baltimore Orioles Stop Coming To Feeders, Cucumber Java Tutorial, Trader Joe's Bean And Cheese Burrito Nutrition, Carbon Steel Pan And Tomatoes, Verbs Ppt Grade 8, Raw Tapioca Calories, Facts About St Cecilia, Indispensable In Spanish,